September and October are my favorite months to lean into all things spooky, atmospheric, and autumnal. Whether you’re into suspense, gothic classics, dark academia, or cozy witchy romances, there’s a perfect book (or stack of them) to keep you company as the nights grow longer.
✨ My favorite Spooky Season author: Simone St. James
If you haven’t picked up Simone St. James yet, now is the time. Her books strike the perfect balance between spooky and suspenseful, with just enough ghostly atmosphere to keep you reading past midnight. What I love most is the historical thread woven into each story—spanning from the 1920s to the 1990s—so there’s a little something for everyone. You can start with any of her books, depending on your “flavor” preference, but her more recent ones lean even more into the suspense side.
📚 Reader recommendation: The Broken Girls (creepy boarding school + murder mystery), The Sun Down Motel (dual timeline ghost story in a rundown motel), or The Book of Cold Cases (true-crime blogger meets a haunted house).
🔪 Suspense & Thriller Favorites: Riley Sager and More
If your spooky season tastes lean more toward psychological thrillers and page-turning suspense, Riley Sager is a must-read. His books feel like watching your favorite scary movie — tense, twisty, and full of atmosphere. Each one has a different hook that will keep you guessing until the very end.
📚 Some recommendations:
- Home Before Dark — a haunted house story with a twist.
- The Last Time I Lied — summer camp secrets and lies.
- Survive the Night — a road trip thriller that reads like a Hitchcock film.
And if you love Sager, you might also enjoy authors like Alice Feeney (Sometimes I Lie), Megan Miranda (All the Missing Girls), or Jennifer McMahon (The Drowning Kind, The Children on the Hill).
🕯️ The Gothic Classics
Sometimes, nothing beats going back to the roots of spooky storytelling. Books like Dracula by Bram Stoker, Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier, And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie, and Interview with a Vampire by Anne Rice are absolute masterclasses in the horror and supernatural genres. These are the stories that set the tone for so many modern tales.
My personal favorite is Rebecca—with its twisty, unsettling atmosphere and an ending that is chef’s kiss.
📖 Dark Academia (or just Academia)
September always feels like back-to-school season, so it’s the perfect time to dive into a book with an academic edge. Whether you go full-on dark academia with eerie, secretive settings, or just pick something with a school/university backdrop, these reads fit the vibe of crisp autumn days and candlelit nights.
Some great options:
- The Secret History by Donna Tartt — the dark academia classic, full of secrets and obsession.
- Babel by R.F. Kuang — historical fantasy + academia, full of language, magic, and rebellion.
- If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio — Shakespeare, theater kids, and a murder mystery.
- A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness — romance, history, and academia with a witchy twist.
- The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova— an age-long mystery, a race across Europe, and a hunt for Dracula
🍁 Comfy Fall Reads
Of course, spooky season isn’t just about being spooked—it’s also about coziness. For me, that means sweet, romantic stories, especially if they have a witchy element. Think cozy romances that make you want to wrap up in a blanket with a mug of tea.
Some to try:
- The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling — witchy rom-com with small town fall vibes.
- Payback’s a Witch by Lana Harper — sapphic romance + magical tournament.
- The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna — found family + heartwarming romance.
- Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman — a witchy classic with beautiful prose.
✨ Whether you’re in the mood for a ghostly chill, a gothic masterpiece, a sharp academic mystery, or a cozy romance with a touch of magic, there’s no better time to build your spooky season TBR.
Here is a very ambitious list of books I hope to read this Spooky Season:
- Murder Road by Simone St. James (Supernatural Suspense)
- A
Dark and Secret Magic by Wallis Kinney (Cozy Witchy Romance) The Haunting of Maddy Clare by Simone St. James (Historical Supernatural Suspense)- One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig (Dark Fantasy)
The Bewitching by Sivia Garcia Moreno (Gothic Horror x Dark Academia)- Not Quite Dead Yet by Holly Jackson (Murder Mystery x Suspense)
- Hemlock & Silver by T Kingfisher (Dark Fantasy)
Wild Hunt by Emma Seckel (Historical Supernatural Suspense)Secrets in the Mist by Anna Lee Huber (Gothic Historical Romance)
I’m eager to see how many I can check off by midnight on Halloween!

